Define: Lucas Direction

Lucas Direction
Lucas Direction
Quick Summary of Lucas Direction

A Lucas direction is a legal instruction given by a judge to a jury in a criminal trial regarding the assessment of evidence related to the defendant’s state of mind. It originated from the English case of R v Lucas and is typically given when the defendant’s state of mind, such as intention or knowledge, is an essential element of the offense being charged. The Lucas direction advises the jury that if they find certain facts to be true, then they must infer or draw conclusions about the defendant’s state of mind based on those facts. The purpose of a Lucas direction is to guide the jury in properly applying the law to the evidence presented during the trial, particularly when determining the defendant’s culpability or mental state in committing the alleged offence.

Full Definition Of Lucas Direction

Guidance from the judge to the jury that the fact that the defendant has told lies, or is alleged to have told lies, does not in itself indicate guilt. The jury should be invited to consider other explanations why the defendant might have lied, including any he proffers himself during the trial. A Lucas direction is unnecessary in cases where the defendant’s untruthfulness is a key feature of the prosecution case — where, for example, guilt or innocence turns on whether the defendant is to be believed or not. The direction is more appropriate where there is a risk that the jury will infer guilt from some lie told that is collateral to the prosecution case.

In R v Burge And Pegg 1996 the Court of Appeal identified four main circumstances in which a Lucas direction should be given:

  1. The prosecution alleges that the defendant lied about his alibi, or the defendant admits to doing so. There are a number of possible explanations for giving a false alibi, not all of which contribute to the strength of the prosecution case. For example, if an assault took place outside a pub, a suspect might originally tell the police that he was at work at the time of the offence, and not in the pub. If it comes to light during the trial that he was in the pub, after all, he might offer the explanation that he had skived off work early and didn’t want his employer to know. This may be discreditable behaviour, and the fact that he was in the pub has substantial probative value. But the fact that he lied about being in the pub has, in itself, little additional probative value.
  2. The judge feels that the jury should consider whether it is necessary to look for corroboration of a particular piece of prosecution evidence, and that corroboration is most likely to be found in the defendant’s untruthfulness. For example, where the defendant refutes the identification evidence of a witness, the judge (mindful of the Turnbull direction) may invite the jury to consider whether there is any other evidence to support the identification. If the suspect has lied about his whereabouts, the jury may infer that this lie is supportive of the identification evidence, whereas, in fact, it is not.
  3. The prosecution is inviting the jury to infer guilt from the defendant’s lies about a collateral issue
  4. The circumstances or presentation of the case makes for a real risk that the jury will make such an inference, even without the encouragement of the prosecution
Related Phrases
No related content found.
Disclaimer

This site contains general legal information but does not constitute professional legal advice for your particular situation. Persuing this glossary does not create an attorney-client or legal adviser relationship. If you have specific questions, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.

This glossary post was last updated: 29th March, 2024.

Cite Term

To help you cite our definitions in your bibliography, here is the proper citation layout for the three major formatting styles, with all of the relevant information filled in.

  • Page URL:https://dlssolicitors.com/define/lucas-direction/
  • Modern Language Association (MLA):Lucas Direction. dlssolicitors.com. DLS Solicitors. March 29, 2024 https://dlssolicitors.com/define/lucas-direction/.
  • Chicago Manual of Style (CMS):Lucas Direction. dlssolicitors.com. DLS Solicitors. https://dlssolicitors.com/define/lucas-direction/ (accessed: March 29, 2024).
  • American Psychological Association (APA):Lucas Direction. dlssolicitors.com. Retrieved March 29, 2024, from dlssolicitors.com website: https://dlssolicitors.com/define/lucas-direction/