Convexity Bias

Business, Legal & Accounting Glossary

Definition: Convexity Bias


Quick Summary of Convexity Bias


A bias in Eurodollar futures rates that makes them slightly higher than corresponding forward rates.




Full Definition of Convexity Bias


Cox, Ingersoll, and Ross (1981) and Jarrow and Oldfield (1981) suggest that daily margin payments on futures may cause forward and futures prices to diverge. If there is a correlation between daily futures prices and interest rates, one party to a futures contract will tend to receive margin payments on days when interest rates rise and make margin payments on days when interest rates decline. On average, she will invest the margin payments she receives at interest rates that are higher than those at which she finances the margin payments she makes. The other party will experience the opposite situation. This should cause a divergence in forward and futures prices. The effect should increase with the maturity of contracts and with the standard deviation of a future’s price.

Empirical studies by Cornell and Reinganum (1981), French (1983), and Park and Chen (1985) confirm a modest effect in gold, silver, silver coins, platinum, copper, and plywood prices but fail to find one for various currencies.

For Eurodollar futures (and other Eurocurrency futures) the effect is exasperated. Not only do the forward rates they are linked to correlate highly with the overnight rates at which margin payments would typically be financed or invested, but there is an issue with how those margin payments are calculated.

A forward on a deposit has convexity. Its market value rises more for a given decline in the forward rate than it would decline for the same sized rise in the forward rate. If this were also true for Eurodollar futures, this convexity effect would partially offset the margining effect identified by Cox, Ingersoll, and Ross (1981) and Jarrow and Oldfield (1981). But it is not true of Eurodollar futures. Contract specifications for Eurodollar futures set the daily margin payment at USD 25 per basis point move in the futures rate. While this margining formula couldn’t be simpler, by construction, it deprives Eurodollar futures of the convexity possessed by the forward rate agreements (FRAs) they are intended to mimic.

Eurodollar futures rates should diverge slightly from corresponding forward rates for FRAs. Burghardt and Hoskins (1995) have called the effect a convexity bias. Note that convexity bias is due to a combination—interaction—of both

  • the margining effect identified by Cox, Ingersoll, and Ross (1981) and Jarrow and Oldfield (1981), and
  • the unique margining formula for Eurodollar futures (and other Eurocurrency futures).

For short-dated Eurodollar futures—those out to a year or eighteen months, the effect is hardly noticeable, a basis point or less. For longer-dated futures, convexity bias can be more pronounced, causing Eurodollar futures rates to exceed corresponding forward rates by ten basis points or more at the longest maturities. The actual magnitude depends on the level and volatility of interest rates. Hull[1] provides the following approximation

Forward Rate[1]
where

  • σ is the standard deviation of the underlying interest rate;
  • t1 is the time (in years) until maturity of the futures contract; and
  • t2 is the time (in years) until the maturity of the underlying loan.

For example, if the 3-month Libor has a standard deviation of 0.012 (120 basis points), the three-year Eurodollar futures rate will be

Forward Rates Example[2]
or 7 basis points higher than the corresponding FRA rate. The approximation assumes both the futures and FRA rates are continuously compounded. Hull cites no source and offers no justification for the formula other than to say it is based on the Ho-Lee interest rate model.

Prior to the early 1990s, traders were unaware of the convexity bias. Eurodollar futures were used to hedge interest rate swaps, which were priced using Eurodollar futures rates as if they were forward rates. This caused swap rates to be higher than they should have been. The situation started to change during the early 1990s, as awareness of the convexity bias spread. Financial engineering models were developed to calculate the convexity bias, which was then taken into account whenever swaps were priced or hedged with Eurodollar futures.

Eurodollar futures are still widely used for hedging swaps and other fixed-income derivatives, but convexity bias has rendered Eurodollar rates a poor benchmark for pricing other instruments. Today, the LIBOR-swap curve has replaced Eurodollar rates as a benchmark.


Cite Term


To help you cite our definitions in your bibliography, here is the proper citation layout for the three major formatting styles, with all of the relevant information filled in.

Page URL
https://payrollheaven.com/define/convexity-bias/
Modern Language Association (MLA):
Convexity Bias. PayrollHeaven.com. Payroll & Accounting Heaven Ltd. September 18, 2021 https://payrollheaven.com/define/convexity-bias/.
Chicago Manual of Style (CMS):
Convexity Bias. PayrollHeaven.com. Payroll & Accounting Heaven Ltd. https://payrollheaven.com/define/convexity-bias/ (accessed: September 18, 2021).
American Psychological Association (APA):
Convexity Bias. PayrollHeaven.com. Retrieved September 18, 2021, from PayrollHeaven.com website: https://payrollheaven.com/define/convexity-bias/

Definition Sources


Definitions for Convexity Bias are sourced/syndicated and enhanced from:

  • A Dictionary of Economics (Oxford Quick Reference)
  • Oxford Dictionary Of Accounting
  • Oxford Dictionary Of Business & Management

This glossary post was last updated: 4th August, 2021 | 73 Views.